Episode 283November 18, 2026

Ben Felix on Simple Investing and Rethinking Retirement Risk

How do you know whether a more sophisticated portfolio is actually a better one? Ben Felix joins me to explore the gap between compelling research and investing decisions you can live with, including some ideas that have challenged his own thinking.

Watch now

Listen now

Now playing · The Long-Term Investor
In this episode

Show Notes

A strategy can look compelling in academic research and still be difficult to live with. Before adding it to a portfolio, we need to understand what it costs, how it might disappoint, and whether we could stick with it when it does.

In this episode, I’m joined by Ben Felix, Chief Investment Officer at PWL Capital and co-host of the Rational Reminder podcast. I’ve long admired Ben’s ability to take academic research and explain it in ways investors can actually use. Our conversation focuses on the judgment required to turn that research into a real portfolio.

We discuss why Ben has moved some clients toward simpler portfolios, how to distinguish useful learning from constant tinkering, and what a controversial study has changed about the way he explains retirement risk. We also explore why good savers often struggle to spend and how his thinking has evolved on both leveraged ETFs and the role of a financial advisor.

For more on investing and financial planning, join my newsletter.

When academic research should change how you invest (00:28)

I begin by asking Ben what separates an interesting research finding from something that should actually change how we invest.

He jokes that for every PhD, there is an equal and opposite PhD. Even foundational ideas in finance have a substantial body of research challenging them. Finding a paper that supports an investment approach is only a starting point.

Ben’s first filter is practical applicability. Market efficiency is a good example. Academics can debate whether markets are perfectly efficient, but most investors should probably behave as though prices incorporate information quickly enough to make consistently outsmarting the market extremely difficult.

That does not mean prices are always right. As I explain, finding a $20 bill on the sidewalk does not mean you should quit everything else and spend your life looking for money on the ground. An occasional opportunity does not establish a repeatable strategy.

Ben adds another question that I think belongs in every investor’s decision process: “What if the research is wrong?”

A backtest might suggest that a concentrated portfolio of 20 stocks with high turnover will outperform. But if the finding fails to hold up beyond the data used to develop it, the investor still bears the concentration, fees, and trading costs. The potential benefit needs to be weighed against the consequences of being wrong.

Why a simpler portfolio can create a better investment experience (03:59)

I ask Ben whether he would build portfolios differently if clients only saw the outcome and never looked at the underlying holdings.

He says this is generally not a major issue with individual clients, but institutional clients have presented a different challenge. PWL historically used Dimensional funds extensively with institutions. Over time, the firm found that investment committees placed substantial weight on performance relative to their benchmarks.

Committee members face reputational concerns, and membership changes. An approach everyone understands today may need to be explained again when new members arrive. Periods of underperformance can repeatedly reopen the same debate about why the portfolio differs from a market index.

PWL responded by moving its institutional portfolios largely toward market-cap-weighted index funds. Ben says the change improved the investment experience and helped the firm win institutional business.

His own volunteer work on a community foundation’s investment committee helped him appreciate the problem. To someone unfamiliar with Dimensional’s approach, it can look like another manager doing something different from the market and offering a story about why it should work.

We discuss why a portfolio must fit the people responsible for maintaining it. An institution with a rotating committee faces different challenges from an individual investing for retirement, even when both understand the same research.

The tradeoffs between simplicity and factor investing (07:20)

We turn to what makes a potential improvement worth additional complexity.

Ben describes a hypothetical portfolio emphasizing small companies, value, profitability, and momentum. There might be substantial academic support for its expected returns, but that would not make it the right portfolio for everyone. Investors would still need to accept its costs and the degree to which its performance could differ from the broader market.

That difference is often described as tracking error. It can be uncomfortable even when the portfolio is behaving as expected.

Ben explains that the Dimensional portfolios PWL uses tilt toward small-cap, value, and profitable companies without becoming radically different from an index portfolio. The deviations are meaningful, but the firm can explain them and reaffirm why it owns those investments.

I point out that a portfolio targeting those characteristics can still be relatively simple. Ben agrees that complexity depends on the audience and the goal. Even traditional indexes have rules governing which companies they include and how they rebalance.

There is no universal boundary between simple and complex. The practical question is whether the investor understands the tradeoffs well enough to accept them.

Why Ben sees part of his job as protecting clients from complexity (10:58)

Ben describes a significant part of his role as “protecting our firm from complexity.”

We discuss separately managed accounts, long-short strategies, private investments, and newer ETFs marketed to investors who already appreciate low-cost indexing or factor investing. As more strategies become accessible, advisors and investors have more opportunities to add something that sounds sophisticated.

Some of PWL’s decisions reflect its operating environment in Canada. Certain strategies cannot be implemented through its custodian. But Ben’s preference for simplicity goes beyond access. PWL has explored separately managed accounts for clients with particular customization needs and ultimately decided that the implications did not justify moving away from funds.

His broader concern is that complex strategies can be harder to evaluate. Investors need to understand what a strategy is intended to do, what outcomes they should reasonably expect, and whether the actual experience supports continuing to own it.

Ben also sees increasingly complicated products being marketed to the same investors and advisors who embraced indexing. Some have research behind them, but he questions how strong that evidence is and whether the additional complexity is worthwhile.

This is one reason he is cautious about the label “evidence-based.” Evidence exists for many approaches. The label alone does not tell you how persuasive the research is or how well the strategy fits a particular investor.

How to tell whether an investment really improves a portfolio (14:24)

As chief investment officers, Ben and I are regularly presented with ideas that supposedly improve a portfolio. I explain that I am more concerned about implementing a bad idea than missing a good one. That creates a high bar for adding something new.

Ben shares that preference. PWL has considered private assets, long-short strategies, and other approaches marketed as extensions of factor investing. The firm has remained hesitant to move beyond Dimensional and index funds. Its most significant departure from its usual models has been toward greater simplicity for institutional clients.

We discuss why expected returns and diversification are only part of the decision. Investors also need to stay with the approach through disappointing periods.

I explain that a benchmark helps us ask good questions about performance. If a holding trails its benchmark, we should be able to explain why and assess whether the original rationale still holds.

Ben offers a useful test: if he cannot make a clear, roughly 15-minute YouTube explanation of why a strategy makes sense, he is uncomfortable putting it into client portfolios. That explanation must remain credible when performance is disappointing.

His clients also hold the firm accountable. Many arrive after listening to hours of the podcast and understanding its philosophy. Introducing an unfamiliar strategy requires a strong case that both the research and the client experience justify the change.

When learning about investing becomes too much tinkering (20:10)

There is always another idea to explore or another portfolio detail to optimize. I ask Ben how investors can tell when that effort is helping and when it has become a distraction.

He looks at what the learning causes someone to do. Content that reinforces a sensible strategy or helps an investor make a thoughtful decision can be valuable. Content that repeatedly triggers trades or changes in asset allocation may be doing harm.

Ben sees both patterns in the Rational Reminder community. Some members frequently rethink their portfolios. Others listen to hundreds of episodes, decide to become clients, and then stop listening because they feel comfortable delegating the work.

That second outcome is revealing. The education helped those listeners reach a decision they trusted, which freed them from feeling they needed to keep studying investing indefinitely.

I describe two common motivations for portfolio changes: wanting exposure to an exciting idea, such as AI, or becoming more conservative because of the crisis of the day. Those motivations deserve scrutiny.

A change in your family, employment, or financial plan can justify a different allocation. A new view about the world is a different kind of input. Ben adds that an occasional, deliberate change can be reasonable. The warning sign is repeatedly abandoning one approach for the next.

What a controversial retirement study teaches us about risk (25:57)

I ask Ben about the research he has described as the most controversial paper in finance: Beyond the Status Quo: A Critical Assessment of Lifecycle Investment Advice, by Aizhan Anarkulova, Scott Cederburg, and Michael S. O’Doherty.

Ben explains that the researchers assembled a large dataset covering 39 developed countries, with some histories extending back to 1890. They used a method called block bootstrap to build one million simulated outcomes from historical returns for stocks, bonds, and bills.

The headline finding challenges familiar retirement advice: within the study’s framework, a 100% stock portfolio was optimal, including during retirement. Bonds did not enter the optimal allocation.

Ben is careful about the limits of that conclusion. The study considers nominal bonds, and its international sample includes severe historical experiences in countries such as Germany and Japan. Whether those experiences are informative for today’s investors is part of the debate. Historical data also cannot tell us exactly what the next several decades will bring.

The research has primarily influenced how Ben talks to clients about risk. If you need $100,000 for a purchase next year, a sharp stock market decline could derail that plan. Over a short horizon, volatility matters enormously.

For a goal 40 years away, cash and short-term investments introduce another concern: losing purchasing power to inflation. Stocks fluctuate more, but they may better support spending needs over very long periods.

Ben explicitly says PWL has not moved all its clients into 100% stock portfolios. The study has helped the firm explain risk without becoming a prescription that every client should follow.

Why having enough to retire changes the risk conversation (31:05)

I connect this research to a question that came up during my book tour: if you have already won the game financially, should you take less risk?

Before answering, we need to define risk. Short-term fluctuations and the ability to support spending over several decades are different concerns. Moving toward bonds may reduce volatility while also reducing the real return someone expects over a long retirement.

At the same time, a financial model can show that someone has room to own more stocks than they would feel comfortable holding. Living through a major decline is very different from looking at a projection. An allocation that seems attractive on paper can fail if the investor cannot maintain it.

I explain that many of the people we work with have strong enough financial plans to choose among several reasonable allocations. Their goals and preferences matter. The research can inform the conversation, but the decision still needs to account for the spending the portfolio must support and the experience the investor can tolerate.

Why good savers struggle to spend in retirement (33:15)

Even someone who gets the investment decisions right can struggle with what comes next. I ask Ben what good savers most often misunderstand about spending their money.

The habits that helped them accumulate wealth can be difficult to change. Some clients have enough to support their current lifestyle, or even a higher level of spending, but still feel uncomfortable using the money.

Ben describes how this can affect couples. One spouse might want to upgrade a flight to business class while the other resists, even when the financial plan supports the expense. Demonstrating that something is affordable does not necessarily resolve the emotional disagreement.

Advisors can offer reassurance and help people identify spending that matters to them. Ben mentions experiences, family, and giving. Yet some people still feel bad spending, regardless of what the numbers or research suggest.

We discuss the tension between running out of money and dying with regret. The useful part of the “die with zero” mentality, in this conversation, is being deliberate about spending while you can enjoy it.

Ben describes varying projected spending over retirement and helping clients think about giving during their lifetimes. Funding family trips, bringing people together, or helping adult children buy a home can allow someone to see the benefit of their wealth while they are alive.

For a lifelong saver, that shift may take practice. A financial plan can show what is possible, but people may also need help becoming comfortable acting on it.

What Ben has changed his mind about (37:01)

I close by asking Ben where research or experience has changed his thinking.

His recent example is leveraged ETFs. He previously treated volatility decay as a reason these products were generally unsuitable for long-term investors. After a listener challenged that view, he revisited the research and found newer papers that led him to a more nuanced conclusion.

Ben now sees circumstances in which leveraged ETFs may be a reasonable source of leverage for long-term investors. His point is not a blanket endorsement. Earlier in our conversation, he distinguishes analyzing a product from recommending it. Here, he explains why the categorical view he once held no longer captures his understanding of the evidence.

His larger change concerns the role of a financial advisor. Early in his career, Ben thought advisors should handle financial planning and asset allocation while leaving clients to decide what they wanted their lives to look like.

Working with Brian Portnoy challenged that assumption. Ben initially resisted the idea that advisors should help with that broader question, but eventually came to see it as fundamental. PWL now has a structured process to help clients define meaningful goals and reflect on what a good life looks like for them.

I share how we think about this at Plancorp, where we also work with Portnoy’s company, Shaping Wealth. An advisor can serve as a “ghost writer for the story of your life,” helping you act on things you might otherwise postpone.

That can mean encouraging a client to spend more. I sometimes tell people that working with us might make their net worth go down because we will encourage them to use money to live the life they actually want. The investment portfolio supports that purpose.

Resources

Submit Your Question for the Podcast

Have a question you would like me to address in a future episode? Use the Ask Me Anything form on my podcast page.

Support the Show

If you found this conversation helpful, share it with someone who would enjoy it or leave a review on your podcast app. Your support helps more listeners discover The Long Term Investor.

Disclosure: This content, which contains security-related opinions and/or information, is provided for informational purposes only and should not be relied upon in any manner as professional advice, or an endorsement of any practices, products or services. There can be no guarantees or assurances that the views expressed here will be applicable for any particular facts or circumstances, and should not be relied upon in any manner. You should consult your own advisers as to legal, business, tax, and other related matters concerning any investment.

The commentary in this “post” (including any related blog, podcasts, videos, and social media) reflects the personal opinions, viewpoints, and analyses of the Plancorp LLC employees providing such comments, and should not be regarded the views of Plancorp LLC. or its respective affiliates or as a description of advisory services provided by Plancorp LLC or performance returns of any Plancorp LLC client.

References to any securities or digital assets, or performance data, are for illustrative purposes only and do not constitute an investment recommendation or offer to provide investment advisory services. Charts and graphs provided within are for informational purposes solely and should not be relied upon when making any investment decision. Past performance is not indicative of future results. The content speaks only as of the date indicated. Any projections, estimates, forecasts, targets, prospects, and/or opinions expressed in these materials are subject to change without notice and may differ or be contrary to opinions expressed by others.

Please see disclosures here.

Free Assessment

See where your finances actually stand

A short, no-pressure review of the fundamentals, savings, investments, taxes, and fees. No cost, no obligation.

Take the assessment
The Long Term Investor podcast

About the Podcast

The Long Term Investor

Long term investing made simple. Most people enter the markets without understanding how to grow their wealth over the long term or clearly hit their financial goals. The Long Term Investor shows you how to proactively minimize taxes, hedge against rising inflation, and ride the waves of volatility with confidence.

Hosted by advisor, Chief Investment Officer of Plancorp, and author ofMaking Money Simple, Peter Lazaroff shares practical advice on how to make smart investment decisions your future self will thank you for. A go-to source for top media outlets like CNBC, the Wall Street Journal, and CNN Money, Peter unpacks the clear, strategic, and calculated approach he uses to decisively manage billions in investments for clients at Plancorp.

Stay informed

Get the newsletter

Every other week, a short read on investing that’s worth your time.

Or subscribe on